Editorial Vol. 1

Legislative Decree 18 April 2016, n. 50, art. 23 Paragraph 13 (design levels for contracts, works and services), the so-called MIT decree (Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport), literally reads: “The contracting entities may require for new works as well as for recovery, refurbishment or variations, primarily for complex works, the use of specific electronic methods and tools referred to in subparagraph 1(h). These tools make use of interoperable platforms by means of open formats, in order not to restrict competition among technology providers and the use of specific planning tools by designers. The use of electronic methods and instruments can be requested only by the contracting entities with properly trained staff (omissis)”.
This is the transposition of the Community Directive 2014/24/EU of the European Parliament and the Council of 26 February 2014.

After about a year, in 2017, the legislative implementing policy is being defined. It is the direct outcome of the measure referred to above (predictably, as a Decree of the Ministry of Infrastructure). Two presumably effective tools are emerging: one is more operational and provides for a national standardization, while the second one is more informative and promotional:
– UNI 11337:2017 (published in several parts, nearing completion);
– The Handbook for the introduction of Building Information Modeling by the European Public Sector. Strategic action for construction sector performance: driving value, innovation and growth published by the EUBIM Taskgroup.

The Building Information Modeling (BIM), along with the above-mentioned standards and recommendations, is therefore recognized as the key information tool for digitalization in the construction sector.
Francesco Ruperto, an expert in this field, says: “Both the MIT decree and the BIM Handbook, a document of reference for the European public demand, identify common and increasingly organized methods to enable a public entity to implement BIM processes in its own organization given their significance with respect to the requirements included in the tender specifications”.
After identifying the common methods of BIM processes, it is necessary to define their qualitative characteristics. Is BIM procedure identical in every intervention area? Why some permutations of Information Modeling are becoming popular, e.g. HBIM (Heritage BIM), LIM (Landscape Information Modeling), GeoBIM (Geospatial BIM), SeismicBIM, etc.? Can we identify virtuous procedures or are there considerable variations from one area to another?
The support offered by various forms of representation to sophisticated knowledge and ideation processes is gaining popularity within increasingly integrated and interconnected computing environments that are gradually overcoming the mere paper-based format. Representation results from an orderly or orderable system of elements that together establish relations, matches, dependencies.
The digital information modeling is the container and, at the same time, the content of knowledge-promoting data. It is shaping its own founding paradigms for a continuously evolving context that affects both the legislative framework in the field of public works and methods and technological tools.
Today, increasingly large skill-based working teams face, through the constant updating of standards and procedures, several challenges that in turn broaden the horizon of possibilities. It is therefore important to have an up-to-date state-of-the-art, built through good practices and the most advanced experience, both in the professional field and in that of theoretical and applied research. This will be used for comparisons or personalized replications.
The research is complemented by increasingly frequent BIM meetings, both at a national and international level, open to academics, professionals, public and private operators. It is worth mentioning a few of them, such as: Workshop 3D Modeling & BIM in 2016 and 2017 held at the Faculty of Architecture in Rome; Brainstorming BIM, held at the Faculty of Architecture of Politecnico of Milan in 2016; BIM and HBIM between Research and Profession, Federazione degli Ordini degli Ingegneri dell’Umbria, Ordine degli Ingegneri of the Province of Perugia and Terni, at UmbriaFiere in Bastia Umbra; Digital & BIM Italy, 2017, at Fair of Bologna.
BIM integrates and is supplemented by other approaches based on specific IT technologies: GIS (Geographic Information System), web, mobile applications, Database Management Systems (DBMS); computer languages linking together the various parts of the building process become the universe of reference for the magazine Dn. Out of the existing trade publications, this new magazine represents a unique experience at national level. It addresses specific themes through an unprecedented analytical approach. It discusses sophisticated and interoperable processes and presents a varied selection of methods, technologies and instruments clearly defined to “build right and allow people to live”.
It aims at becoming a critical reference for a heterogeneous public, composed of researchers and operators in the field of construction; an investigation and comparison tool where professionals, experts and researchers may discuss, propose solutions or share and illustrate the path followed in the definition of individual projects.

The first issue presents a collection of the most interesting scientific contributions arising from the above mentioned training activities. The magazine content is quite diversified. It presents exploratory approaches in the field of H-BIM, aimed at a correct digitization of historical heritage, semantically intelligent, with interesting methodological insights; a number of virtuous examples of good practices for the implementation of major building interventions characterized by marked process innovations, a description of operational proposals and related applications in the managing/maintenance area. These contributions reflect an integrated methodological approach that should allow preserving, looking up and updating the information heritage in accordance with interoperable operational processes and a strongly collaborative spirit.

 

T. Empler, M. Lo Turco


Editorial Vol. 2

Until a few years ago, talking about BIM or H-BIM was a subject dealt with by the few brave pioneers specializing in designing on an international scale; today the BIM approach has become a “must” of planning, rehabilitation, re-functionalization, restoration, recovery, etc.
The use of BIM techniques has had such an increase, sensitizing researchers to experiment with new and more effective applications. The solicitations that constantly come from the professional world, have opened a very wide window in the CH field; both with regard to its problems and ways of overcoming them.
And although the field of cultural heritage is the confluence of the largest number of trials, the engineering fields have also turned their attention to BIM applications. This includes road engineering, hydraulic engineering, railway engineering, structural and energy engineering; in short, to all the sectors involved in a Smart City, which today more than ever, needs a Smart BIM methodology.
The ability to query a three-dimensional model to extrapolate all the information needed for new interventions on a work, optimizes timing and results of the operations to be performed. The BIM paths become increasingly rich and articulated and open to meet the needs of all those practitioners that are involved in a structure built or to be built, in a good state of conservation or to restructure, restore, recover, etc.
Think of the electrical and hydraulic systems, the structural system, the furnishings, the closing elements, the materials used, etc. Obviously, the more complex the information structure to be set out, the more complex the algorithm that supports this scaffolding becomes.
An extremely vast subject and, for that reason, it lends itself to misunderstandings that are not always easy to identify. In addition to frequent misunderstandings, difficulties are encountered in trying to integrate data related to models made with different software. It appears, therefore, that interoperability is a problem in practice much more complex than claimed at the theoretical level.
In this issue of the Dn journal, there are 8 articles that allow the reader to learn both the state of the advances in literature, the operations of new mathematical algorithms and the computational designs that, thanks to the experiments conducted, allow more and more new applications. BIM techniques are often adopted to solve the difficulties related to the management of production / construction / intervention / construction / sustainability costs.
In this issue there are some works that deal with BIM under other aspects in very different contexts; with characteristics and needs sometimes in contrast and this allows us to be able to understand some essential aspects that become a paradigm, an archetype of operating methodologies.
Furthermore, the BIM experimentation in the GIS field is very timely so as to obtain the territorial data for the development of City Information Modelling (CIM) using open source data and geospatial surveys.
A need that has arisen spontaneously as the BIM system has entered into the design and redevelopment of the building, is that of the need to codify a new parameter, the Level of Reliability, which takes into account both the geometric and semantic-ontological reliability of the model with respect to the reality it intends to describe. Hence the need to code a set of shared and repeatable parameters to arrive at a numerical evaluation of LOR synthesis, which is understood as the level of global coherence of the process of defining a digital object.
One of the goals that BIM scholars and experimenters intend to achieve is that of remote application directly in-situ. In this way, you have the ability to update in real time, make any changes, annotate considerations, identify points of fragility or strength, etc. and see the system’s response on the server. Moreover, through the application of the computational design it is possible to speed up and improve the realization of complex geometries typical of historical architecture and to automate some processes during the design phase.
Exploring the new frontiers of BIM through the use of algorithmic tools for the control of the formal and informative aspects of the project represents, today, a real revolution in terms of the optimization of the tangled and sometimes indestructible machine for the design of building structures and civil infrastructures.

 

Laura Inzerillo, Francesco Ruperto


H-BIM modeling and historical reconstruction of architectural heritage

ABSTRACT


The object of this essay is a research about one of the most ancient buildings in Naples, Palazzo Penne, a residential fifteenth-century building which underwent a lot of transformations over time who radically altered its original structure. In particular, a careful multidisciplinary survey was carried out and a 3D BIM model was created, thus focusing on problems and advantages of HBIM systems starting from surveys with range-based technologies.


di S. Scandurra, M. Pulcrano, C. Tarantino, A. di Luggo -
Dipartimento di Architettura, Università di Napoli Federico II


Heritage Bim: methodological reflections and interoperability with numerical simulations

ABSTRACT


Energy efficiency, sustainability of interventions and efficient management of the conservation process are three increasingly important features of the restoration and regeneration of urban historic fabrics. Several studies identify in the Heritage-BIM the most suitable instrument for the integration and management of knowledge produced during the conservation process, with ongoing experiments that, from the field of representation and geometric survey, have gone in the direction of a multidisciplinary approach. Numerical simulations are one of the most powerful tools for improving energy efficiency of the built heritage, not only for the understanding of complex phenomena and the analysis of the energy and environmental consequences of conservation interventions (also in terms of deterioration), but also because they allow innovative applications in the field of non-destructive analysis and in the reconstruction of the original passive behaviour of historic structures. An HBIM model already contains much of the information required for numerical analysis of historical structures, and interoperability can save time by reducing errors in manual steps but at the moment the process of integration between the two software environments is still complex and in an embryonic phase that requires a multidisciplinary approach and the involvement of numerous experts from different scientific fields. The article describes the methodology of integration between multidisciplinary analyses, HBIM modelling and simulation analysis adopted within the METRICS research project, where it was possible to test the limits and potentials of the currently available approaches, exploiting the digital medium of computational design to bridge the gap between BIM and simulation environments.


di Elena Gigliarelli – Institute for Technologies Applied to Cultural Heritage (ITABC) – National Research Council of Italy (CNR)
Filippo Calcerano – ITABC - CNR
Michele Calvano – Sapienza University of Rome
Francesco Ruperto - Sapienza University of Rome
Mario Sacco – Studio Arcrea
Luciano Cessari – ITABC - CNR


Towards a practice of BIM: three case studies

ABSTRACT


The continuous innovation and growing pervasiveness of the new IT tools available to designers are leading to a real integration between the geometric modeling methods and those involved in non-graphic data management, causing consequences that deeply involve all fields of the construction industry.


di A. Cristofolini, G. A. Massari - Università degli studi di Trento


Construction of the new Hospital of the Sibaritide: collaboration strategies for concessions in the BIM environment

ABSTRACT


The authorization process of concessions to the new hospital of the Sibaritide is based on an extremely enlarged project of multidisciplinary collaboration.
The BIM choice (Building Information Modelling) has ensured transparency, accessibility by sharing of responsibilities to the process and experiencing streaming checking almost in real time.


di C. Greco - VALLE3.0 Bim Coordinator


Perugini’s Tree House - BIM ante litteram

ABSTRACT


During the 60s and 70s there was a discreet increase of architectural designs based on the aggregation of modules and their reiteration, concentrating on the main use of structures and reinforced concrete on the facade. It became an architectural movement called Brutalism. Perugini’s Tree House is affected by the influence of Brutalist architecture.
BIM Modelling is based on the use of elements, Families, and their aggregation. The elements are parametric and may vary in size. Construction is carried out by matching the elements. Perugini’s 1970 Tree House is built exactly in this manner.
BIM did not exist in 1970, however, computers did, but were not found in the studios of architects. Perugini didn’t have BIM but he would have certainly have used it if it had existed. The compositional trend of Perugini’s Tree House is based on the use of prefabricated interconnected elements. Observing the Tree House’s modelling has allowed to retrace the design path by decomposing the villa into its constituent elements. The totality of the elements used in the project stems from only 11 families of parametric components which, with their dimensional variations and placed with different orientations, form the complex facades of the villa in Fregene.
The BIM model obtained from the villa was also tested as a 3D database for analysing the state of degradation of the villa itself.


di A. Raimondi, F. Ripoli - Università di Roma Tre - Dipartimento di Architettura


A winning strategy in a BIM process

ABSTRACT


BIM coordination of Doha Major Stations in charge of One Works (Milan, Doha) as project leader. The companies inside the process were Parallel Digital (Roma) for BIM management, HSS (Chennai) as modeler, Inhabit Group (Hong Kong) as lighting design. With the support of previous experiences Parallel Digital designs a strategy, the BIM Implementation Plan. The goal, to develop the BIM strategy, was to define audit procedures for the modeler team and ensure the workflow between Chennai, Hong Kong, Doha, Milan and Rome. In the first phase, about 2 months, was represented the work already done by a previous company in RVT format. Based on existing models for other stations, it was established a basic model strategy, following an advanced model checker system to provide the client the requested quality. In the second phase, about 3 months, was managed the data extraction from the models and the interoperability between the different disciplines. In order to obtain the necessary material to execute the project in an efficient and integrated manner, it was necessary to upgrade the strategy. The result was to obtain in 5 months the BIM model, BOQs, Clash detection and drawing productions in a LOD 300.


di M. Sarrocco, A. Reina Rojas - Parallel Digital s.r.l.


Between CAAD and BIM

ABSTRACT


The essay deals with some issues related to CAAD (Computer Aided Architectural Design) and BIM (Building Information Modeling) analyzing the specificity about the historical condition on main theoretical references. We consider some significant contributions, including those by Nicholas Negroponte and William J. Mitchell regarding CAAD and Charles M. Eastman on BIM.


di A. Sdegno - Università di Udine


A BIM-based approach for building stock maintenance and management

ABSTRACT


Building Information Modelling (BIM) is a collaborative approach to the building process. The goal is to test BIM for Facility Management (FM) by defining the Levels of Development (LODs), worksharing and data visualization for process optimization.


di F. Semeraro, A. Osello, N. Rapetti - Politecnico di Torino